Helen's three forty-something sons are Carl (Börje Ahlstedt), a professor struggling with debt; Gustav (Jarl Kulle), an inveterate drinker and skirt-chaser; and Oscar (Allan Edwall), a glum theater manager. Gustav is married to easygoing Alma (Mona Malm) but has an open affair with Maj (Pernilla August), who is apparently the governess of Alexander (Bertil Guve) and Fanny (Pernilla Alwin). Those two are the pre-teenaged children of Oscar and his beautiful young wife Emilie (Ewa Fröling).
Alas, Oscar dies, and the lonely Emilie turns to icy bishop Edvard (Jan Malmsjö). Edvard, as we suspect all along, turns out to be a harsh authoritarian. A visit from the cagey and perhaps magical Isak allows their escape. By this time, both Emilie and Maj are pregnant, creating further complications within the growing and multi-generation Ekdahl family.
There are two versions of this movie, a five-hour cut for Swedish television, and the three-hour-plus theatrical version with greater mercy on the human bladder.
How others will see it. Perhaps to a degree greater than any other Bergman film, Fanny and Alexander was well received in America. U.S. box office was middling, of course, but the movie received six Oscar nominations and won in four categories, an uncommon achievement for an independent foreign language movie. The two categories in which it was nominated, but missed, were for Best Picture and Best Screenplay.
Today, the film has extremely high user ratings at imdb.com, though the vote total is slightly low, relative to its reputation, at 20K. The movie lurks within the lower reaches of the much-promoted imdb.com Top 250.
The user ratings are consistent with the exception of women over 45, an independent-minded demographic that gives the movie only a 6.5 out of 10. I believe this lower rating comes from a moral disapproval of the characters in the movie, particularly the sex addict Gustav and the child beater and imprisoner Edvard.
How I felt about it. The critic, though, is glad to see Edvard appear on the scene, because the movie then becomes noticeably better. Perhaps the old adage about the necessity of tension in a drama is correct after all. The first half of this very long film is about, as much as anything else, Gustav and his endless compulsion for female flesh. But he is both pathetic and uninteresting.
Edvard, though, creates conflict. He threatens to remove a branch of the Ekdahl family, and the specter of living with him, his dreadful spinster sister Henrietta (Kerstin Tidelius), and his invalid relative Elsa (Hans Henrik Lerfeldt), is akin to serving time in an austere prison where the guards (servants) are informers to the warden (Edvard).
Alas, the "misunderstood" and dislikable Edvard goes the way of Emilie's first husband. Meanwhile, we wonder why the movie is called Fanny and Alexander, when Fanny is merely an overly well-behaved child with few speaking lines, and Alexander's character is little more than a victim of Edvard's misguided sense of parenting.
We feel sorry for Alexander, of course, although in the end he has good prospects since his family is wealthy. He is a bit of a Dickens hero, but less interesting as such, since he merely reacts with mild rebellion (patently absurd stories) to his fate.
Bergman's success with Fanny and Alexander was partly due to marketing and his True Grit John Wayne moment. By that I mean the movie provided an excuse for him to be honored by Oscar, even though, being a foreign production, the movie won only in lesser categories. It was said to be his last theatrical movie, and was also plugged as partly autobiographical, both marketing moves that proved effective.
Like most Bergman movies, though, Fanny and Alexander is often unpleasant, and can be hard to watch. Similar to Wild Strawberries, one of his more famous efforts, there are surreal moments. The dead Oscar pays calls upon his mother and son, but he's no more useful and cheerful than he was when he was alive. There's also an ancient mummy that breathes and glows in the dark, Isak's projection of prone children in the nursery/prison cell, and, weirdest of all, Ismael (Stina Ekblad).
Ismael is obviously played by a woman but has a man's name and an androgynous look. Ismael is considered too dangerous to have contact with others, yet is allowed access alone to an impressionable child on his first visit with her, with arguably evil results.
But at least Ismael is something different, and along with the character of Edvard, and a few good performances (Emilie, Helen, Isak) makes Fanny and Alexander slightly better than it should be. Nonetheless, it is by no means the masterpiece it is often made out to be, and is instead a marginally good film worth the patience required to get through it.